After multiple people urged me to watch Susan Boyle on Britain's Got Talent , I made an occasion of it by actually turning on my home computer - seeing as how my work one has no speakers (and I am too low-tech to figure out where to plug in my headphones. Forgive me, I work on a PC from the stoneage, not very user-friendly to begin with).
OK before hearing her, I had already read that she sang I Dreamed a Dream and wowed everyone. I knew her voice was especially surprising given her appearance, general spastic demeanor and possible channeling of William Hung in the department of naive confidence. Oh and apparently she has a disability, although I am not going to make assumptions about what that is referring to.
Looking at the screenshots, I tried to imagine a buttery I Dreamed a Dream coming out of this woman's voice. I tried but could not imagine it, partly because of the song. I wouldn't consider it the easiest song to blow people away.
So finally, I get home and it's my chance to hear the person who's caused so much hype, to be truly surprised, and... People! The segment was totally packaged to be a tear-jerker, first of all, with the background music. There was also the "cutting away" to the audience's reactions (initial disgust, then awe), which I'm guessing were taken entirely out of context (as in, those poor people's disgusted facial expressions were made during a truly disgusting moment and not when Susan Boyle was speaking).
On to the singing. UGH. I get it, I get that she is confident and has a good personality. Kudos, really! Screw everyone who ever made fun of her, because that's not nice. But her voice only comes as a surprise because she didn't SOUND LIKE WILLIAM HUNG... but that's IT. This is making me all frowny face because it's not talent... it's just... better-than-william-hungness. I don't know how else to put it. The vibrato is scary terrible. She has no low notes. Actually, zero technique. And no emotion to go with this super depressing song. Why is everyone reacting? Because of the darn packaging of the segment! If this were American Idol she would've been one of the BAD ones. Got Talent is a less cynical show than Idol so they decided to go this route with Susan Boyle, but... still... this is such a stretch. She can't sing.
4 comments:
"If this were American Idol she would've been one of the BAD ones"...
I agree.
But I dunno enuf abt the show (Britain's Got Talent) to know whether that's how low their standards are... like maybe cuz it's not primarily a "singing show" they call this kind of thing talent...
oh haha shall we try tackle your headphone issue? do you see a "green" color-code outlet/circle plug you can plug something into? that'd be it! if not, take a picture of your computer-back and send it to me!
lol... one of the problems is i can't get to the back of my comp... b/c it's reli huge and heavy, on my desk (not on the floor) so not much space to turn it around, etc... also i think my headphones are barely long enuf b/c of how the PC is positioned...
but it might be a good thing so i don't watch youtube at work
that's the case! i see! haha maybe u should sneak me into ur office on a wkend n i work on it for u!
Post a Comment