Friday, July 20, 2007

OK now I'm gonna blog about a big pet peeve I have when watching movies! It is when the young and old versions of characters don't look anything alike! This drives me nuts!

1st case in point:
Jack's son from Will & Grace and Tobey Maguire in "Seabiscuit"

I was pretty offended that the casting people thought the audience would accept this pairing as young/old versions. And what age difference are they supposed to play? Tobey Maguire has such a baby face he looks only 5 yrs older, in which case the change in appearance would be way too great.

2nd case in point:

Edison/Andy Lau, Yue Man Lok/ Tony Leung in "Infernal Affairs"
There are some similarities, but I am against the use of different actors for full-grown adults who are supposed to have a mere 10 year age difference. I know, I know, the two younger ones were at least partially used to attract the some screaming girls into the theaters, but still.

3rd case in point:
Wentworth Miller and Anthony Hopkins in "The Human Stain"

Um. People have issues with the casting choice for this movie because this character plays a pale black person, and people think it's impossible to think of Hopkins as black. Well... I think the young/old casting choice is even harder to believe.

4th case in point:
That kid and Christian Bale in "Batman Begins"
They may have cast this kid purely because he's got that traumatized look.


EXAMPLES OF GOOD YOUNG/OLD VERSIONS:

That awesome kid and Audrey in "Amelie"


That kid and Ethan Hawke in "Great Expectations"

That kid and Matt Damon in "The Departed"

EDITED TO ADD: another pairing I think is great is that kid and Collin Farrell in "Alexander."

3 comments:

ampligenic said...

vk... do you still keep up w/ the IMDb discussion on Kavalier... they'll prob screw up the cast by making the mistake you described...

i really think maggie gyllenhaal'd be a good Rosa!!!

knockoutgirl said...

Firstly... I've given up hoping that this movie will ever get made! Can't these people get their act together?

I really think they should use the same actors for young and old characters. They can easily make the story span only around 10 years and age the actors, etc.

I've always thought of Rosa as sort of like Marisa Tomei or Jamie-Lynn Sigler, but that's just me. I know everyone wants Natalie Portman....

I just can't imagine anyone doing the "Lampedusa" part.

ampligenic said...

it annoys me to no end that people want natalie portman. Did they even read the book?